« Questions about the Bible Women | Main | The problem with fundamentalist fundamentalism »

(Link): Women in ministry: why the issue is important

Before I direct you to this link, I just want to say that I am undecided on the question of whether women can share fully in church ministries with men. "Can" here meaning a matter of having permission from God rather than being designed or equipped to, as I would argue that they are. However, I would not suggest that a women who is bearing and raising young children is in a position to do full-time or sometimes even part-time ministry, whether it be allowable otherwise or not.

At Christians for Biblical Equality is a sound defense of why we need to look at (or revisit) the matter of women in ministry. Points cited include the fact that there are still inequities in treatment of the sexes in both society and the church, the fact that evangelicals are divided on the matter, and that

Many evangelicals are inconsistent in the applications of their beliefs. For example, many churches allow women to teach children (the most vulnerable learners) but not adults (who should be able to understand that their teacher is fallible).

Most importantly, "It's not some distant theological issue," but something that we face and deal with daily -- the way that men and women relate is basic to existence. The matter has

immediate implications for our church activities and leadership, for our own identities, for how we raise our kids, for the political issues we stand for, for the way we operate in cross-gender and same-gender relationships.

The article asks that attention be given to the "gender-related brokenness" in our world, since God is in the reconciliation and restoration business, which I believe is true. Yes, He's also in the judgment business. But were He not in the reconciliation and restoration business, there'd be no reason to evangelize, disciple, or minister to the poor and needy. Therefore, as the post says, it is important "to understand exactly what God intends for us as men and women."

We need to understand what wholeness and peace look like when applied to gender so we can pursue those in our own lives and communities.

I would reword that to read "We need to understand what God designed and intended regarding gender so we can pursue this in our own lives and communities.

Comments

It seems that the permission given to women to teach other women and children is predicated on the fact that she doesn't really have the propensity to be deceived, or this propensity is so minuscule it doesn't deserve mention. Or, the most vulnerable are ultimately regarded as the smallest and irrelevant and there is little concern for what they are taught in light of her propensity to deception.

Posted by: Sarah Flashing at June 25, 2008 10:19 AM

From looking at the question for a couple years now I have pretty much come to one conclusion on the issue of women teaching. I think that word "permission" that Sarah uses is pivotal. It all depends on the amount of permission rendered by male leadership. There is a huge area of ground covered in what that permission allows.

I used to think it was pretty useless for Catholic women to appeal or try to make their case for more participation in spiritual leadership, but now I think that is exactly what women should do: persuade men to investigate the permission that is given in scripture that they may implement it in the church body.

The reason women can teach children is because that is what is allowed, supported, and encouraged. That is what is needed in other areas of leadership... it works in a sort of underground de facto sort of way right now, which I think is terribly unfair and discouraging to those who are gifted by the Holy Spirit, but don't have the "feminine charm" or the prestigious relationship to the male leadership which is the present base for a lot of women in ministry (a bit of a reflection of the worldliness that is evident in male leadership sometimes, too!). There are some who climb up as the male leaders do- but that is a long shot from recognition of the calling and anointing of God. It is the reward to ambitious and manipulative personalities. Not that all are under that category -please don't read me that way- but the refusal of leading men to recognize the plain Biblical reasons for women to exercise their spiritual gifts with both approval and support is just a tragedy. That is what leads some to worldly "woman's ways" of gaining position. IMO

I think that is what leads also to the frustration that many gifted women feel in the structure of women's ministries- the bar is just not very high because the leadership is somewhat arbitrary.

I think of it this way: When people pick who they want they get a "Saul", when God picks who He wants and they finally get to exercise their gift, we get a "David".

Now I know this is going to rile some people up- and cause some to jump to conclusions that I'm dissing all those women who do lead or are given roles in the church. But we can all agree that the state of matters is in confusion... and that is less than God's best.

It is an understatement to say the church is inconsistent.

Posted by: Ilona at June 25, 2008 7:26 PM

Well said, Ilona.

As a Children's Ministries Director, I see this kind of thing all the time - from both sides.

Posted by: Kristine at July 1, 2008 7:43 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?






If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.

About

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.