« The Passing of D. James Kennedy | Main | The Legacy of D. James Kennedy »

Bravo, Luciano Pavarotti

As everyone has probably heard, the legendary tenor is dead of pancreatic cancer at age 71. A great artist with a great gift who developed it well and shared it most generously, Pavarotti follows Beverly Sills, the legendary coloratura who died of lung cancer earlier this summer. Both singers did much to not only attain the highest level of their craft but to bring it and its benefits to as many people as possible.

I can't help but wonder, though: as the musical greats, especially ones in the so-called "classical" field, pass on, who will carry on their tradition?

Indeed, will the tradition itself carry on?

Matthew Lee Anderson at Mere Orthodoxy asked this question in a post called Selling Classical Music, to which my good friend Rusty Lopez alerted me. Lee Matt thinks it will, but... He links to an article of the same name by New York drama and music critic Terry Teachout, who in turn links to the blog of classical music critic Greg Sandow, who basically asks the same question.

Both Teachout and Sandow opine upon on the elitism of the classical music world and use terminology of Christian evangelicalism when speaking of the need for classical musicians to be relevant to the modern age and spread the music-appreciation gospel to the masses.

Hmmm.

As a professional classical musician myself (in my spare time), I have a few thoughts and questions about this. I hope to discuss them in the near future.

Meanwhile, I am enjoying the Pavarotti tributes on the radio. Could anyone else make "You'll Never Walk Alone" sound so exquisite and so grand? Bravo, Pavarotti.

Comments

I love classical music, and though I'm an instrumentalist I do actually enjoy opera. ;) Will anyone carry on the tradition of these greats like Pavarotti and Sills? I hesitate when I say this....but have you heard Il Divo?? :)

Posted by: Sarah at September 6, 2007 1:45 PM

I guess I've been under a rock lately- had no idea that Pavarotti passed from this world. The loss of such people impresses us with the incredible value of the unique person. They had a special combination that will be missed and cannot be fully replaced, but the wonderful thing is that there are potentials within humanity to produce something truly amazing with each new generation. There will not be another Pavarotti, but there will be singers who make the heart soar in that way with their own combination of soul and talent. there will those who love classical music and give themselves to it, producing and enjoying.
The thing is to fully enjoy each shining star as it lights up the sky.

Posted by: ilona at September 6, 2007 2:30 PM

Sarah, I've heard of Il Divo but haven't actually heard them. As my husband said, though, there will never be another Pavarotti. There may have been (and will be) tenors as good as him, but he set the bar.

As Teachout says, our culture no longer supports, and probably never again will, a climate in which someone like Pavarotti can triumph. Western music is going a different direction.

I suppose that's inevitable. And I welcome "new revelation," so to speak. But at the same time I hate to see the great tradition go. It represents a pinnacle of human expression, of complexity, and excellence. (Now I sound like a humanist, but I credit God for these things.)

You know, Pavarotti could nail a high f at the top of the treble staff. I can't even do that!! (I'm an alto.)

Posted by: Bonnie at September 6, 2007 11:41 PM

Bonnie,

Thanks for the link. I linked to two pieces in my post, Teachout's and another that was a bit more bullish. I look forward to reading your thoughts as I am pretty conflicted over what I think the future of classical music will look like.

Posted by: Matt Anderson at September 7, 2007 9:08 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?






If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.

About

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.