« International Church Lady | Main | Short ride in a fast machine »

A "Generous" Calvinism in the Las Vegas Airport

While making arrangements to attend GodBlogCon 2007 in Las Vegas, I remembered a book on my shelf I had forgotten to finish reading. "Calvinism in the Las Vegas Airport" was written by Richard Mouw of Fuller Seminary. It's a great read in that it shows the practical side of belief in the 5 points of Calvinism, aka the "TULIP."

I still haven't finished reading it. It's not that it's a large book, I'm just dumbfounded by something I read on page 87. The section is titled "Hoping for Generosity" and he's discussing how some Calvinists insist on playing a numbers game, "insist[ing] that only a very small portion of the human race will make it to heaven...". But Mouw continues, suggesting that he's holding out for a "divine generosity." Here's what he means:

I have a rabbi friend who is now very old. He has often sent me friendly notes about something I have written, and on a number of occasions he has told me that he prays for God's blessing on my work. I have a spiritual hunch about how things are going to end up for this rabbi. I would not be surprised if, when the final encounter comes with his Maker and he sees the face of Jesus, he will bow in worship, acknowledging that Jesus is the One whom he should have named all along as the Promised One of Israel-and that the Savior will welcome him into the eternal kingdom. (p. 87)
Mouw then completes the chapter by discussing the election of infants and those who are unable to respond to the gospel because of disability or geographical distance from the nearest presentation of the gospel. It seems that because mystery surrounds the issue of salvation for some of these people categories, he's willing to posit some sort of salvation experience in the presence of Jesus for his friend the rabbi.

Is anyone else alarmed by this? Whatever your view on election, the TULIP, etc (that is not open for debate in this post, sorry...) Scripture is clear that the born again experience is one of this world and this life or else what is the sense of urgency of the Church for missions and evangelism? Hebrews 9:27 says that "it is appointed to men to die once and after this comes judgement."

I think Mouw's "hunch" about his friend's eternal situation is left a bit ambiguous, it's not all that clear what Mouw is thinking - so I will remain gracious in my assessment until he or someone else can set me straight on this. But I am alarmed.

Comments

My husband has the book and I read it a while back also. Everyone I know (not many people, granted) who has read it picked up on that section also.

It's really disapointing because it's a great little book otherwise.

Posted by: Sheena at August 23, 2007 4:45 PM

In the Catholic Church, it is recognised that there is the possibility of salvation by somehow being part of the mystical body of Christ without formally belonging to it.

The cases in which this happens is totally up to God, and speculation about it differs. It could theoretically include those who have been "psychologically inoculated" by misinformation and/or upbringing to reject Christ even though they technically have heard the Gospel (eg from sources they have been brought up not to trust).

Even so, we Catholics believe that there is definitely no salvation after death.

However, if there are those that are somehow part of Christ and saved in this life even though they don't know it now, then I would imagine that their recognition of the fullness of truth may well come immediately after death.

The way I read Mouw's pasasge above, it could be describing a recognition experience rather than the actual point when they enter a state of grace.

Posted by: Atlantic at August 23, 2007 5:07 PM

I re-read this and I need to clarfy one misstatement:

"to reject Christ even though they technically have heard the Gospel"

What I mean is more like "to falsely believe they have rejected Christ, because they may have technically heard the Gospel but have not formally accepted it (eg because they heard it from sources they believe they have good reason not to trust, or heard it mixed with false teachings, etc.), while actually receiving and responding in their hearts to salvific graces from God."

Posted by: Atlantic at August 23, 2007 6:55 PM

There are a great many evidences of God's graciousness in Scripture, starting with his acceptance of Abraham despite his ignorance about many things, including Christ.

Far from being alarmed, I agree with Mouw, and I don't think the hope for a second chance on the other side of death takes anything away from the imperatives of the commandment of Jesus to go into all the world and make disciples. It's just that like Mouw, I am awed at God's graciousness, and I wonder if he might not create an opportunity for those who need one to repent and believe, even at the gate of judgment.

I have no way of knowing, but it would fit with God's generous character. It is a hope, not an expectation, but a hope that I think is consistent with the character of God.

Posted by: Charlie at August 24, 2007 5:53 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?






If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.

About

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.