« Same as it ever was... | Main | Romance for Grown-up Women »

Links on death and grief

* At Naked Pastor, a fantastic list telling us How to be With Those Who Grieve. The summary: Be There, Shut Up, Be Yourself, Don't Stay Long, Get Physical, Listen, Be With Them, Don't Be Shocked, Comfort, Be Practical, Be Patient.

HT: Rebecca Writes

David also lists 10 Things A Friend's Death Taught Me. This list is as good as the last one. I urge everyone to read them both.


* At The Dawn Treader, an "old" post on the tragic death of a 16-year-old who was hit by a drunk driver, with a recent comment at the bottom by a mother who recently lost her only son. She explains what she's found helpful and comforting in the three months since his death.


* At Done With Mirrors, Callimachus reviews Team of Rivals by Doris Kearns Goodwin and notes the "fearful swath of death" that "[cuts] through young families" in 19th-century life stories:

Researchers into early nineteenth century families quickly come to accept the high death rates among children as a fact of life in those days. Families were large, medicine was crude, disease ran rampant, and it seems no family was untouched by the tragedy of a child lost.

He goes on to detail and give a plethora of examples. After one of these he writes:

It's remarkable that a tragedy so pervading, and so intense, has not been more considered by historians in examining the temper of the times. This grim fact of life seems to me to explain so much about the shape of 19th century American minds, especially where they seem different from ours: The determination to make something of oneself, the importance of family.

...not just the intensity of American religion but the form of it, so full of resurrection and the need to keep in God's good graces at every moment, seems to have been guided by the realities of death in that era. The hope of meeting in another world and knowing one another in the flesh again was the only solace. Lincoln, lacking it, was thrown into despair by the loss of Ann Rutledge.

...Others, faithful, were able to bear the loss by convincing themselves of this theology. Mary Todd, after her child's death, threw herself into the bosom of the Presbyterian church, while Chase, who always was devout, was tormented because his first wife had died without fully affirming her Protestant faith.

Given that, I wonder if it is mere coincidence that the decline in religious intensity among the mass of Americans seems to have begun within a generation of the decline of the child death rate, reversed when medical men and women finally began to understand, and beat back, tuberculosis, typhoid, scarlet fever, diphtheria, and whooping cough.

Thought-provoking.

HT: Ambivablog

Comments

Good links. Although I think the naked guy could have been a bit more human and not so preachy with regards to how he describes point # 2 (Shut Up).

Posted by: Rusty Lopez at February 9, 2007 10:16 AM

Rusty, can you suggest a rewrite of point #2 that would be less preachy?

Posted by: Bonnie at February 9, 2007 12:32 PM

Bonnie,

I infer from point # 2 a disgust at the so-called holier-than-thou crowd in, not surprisingly, a holier-than-thou manner. It appears he believes that if one was to speak the platitudes and cliches, then that person would be implying they've "got it together." Bad deliveries by well intentioned people do not necessarily equate to those who also think they've got it together. I also found his use of "for God's sake" to be tantamount to disrespectful (but I may be mis-reading him there).

Here's my re-write:

Understand the importance of keeping quiet: Instead of reciting well meaning platitude and cliches, which could give the impression that you're claiming to have it together, try to just "be there" for your friend. They don't expect you to wipe away, or even ease, their grief with supposed words of wisdom. But they do expect the presence of a close friend. Don't try and use scripture as some sort of quick-fix, but do impress the resource of God's word as one of the means with which to draw upon the strength He can provide.

Posted by: Rusty at February 9, 2007 1:41 PM

Thanks Bonnie and Intellectuelle for the mention and the links. Glad the two posts are of help!

Posted by: nakedpastor at February 9, 2007 3:02 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?






If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.

About

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.