« Christian Carnival | Main | Power and reason »

Thoughts About Zines

It is common to hear (at Intellectuelle and elsewhere) that Christians to be "counter-cultural", and when I hear that phrase I always think of zines.

A zine is a small paper publication that is usually made by a single person or small group of people, which focuses on their own interests, passions, politics, angst, neurosis, etc. People have been self-publishing books, pamphlets, tracts, etc. since the invention of the printing press. Most zines do not make a profit, but are a labor of love. Zines are a combination of words and/or images, put together in some combination on the page, and then copied, usually on a photocopier at a retail store, or on home copiers. The vast majority of zines published today focus on left-wing politics, sexual identity, feminism, punk rock and other such topics. Despite this depressing focus, the contents of many zines are highly creative, touching, funny or thought provoking.

If you read a book like The Zine Scene by Hillary Carlip and Francesca Lia Block, you can't help but be impressed with the kind of creative honesty coming out of the "angry punk angst-ridden self-mutilating homo, bi and transgendered atheist and/or definitely anti-Christian" subcultures. And whenever I get ready to publish another run of my own zines, I always wonder, "Where are all the Christian zinesters?" Even with the help of the internet, I have not been able to find even one other Christian paper zinemaker (If you know one or ARE one, please let me know). At first glance, this may be chalked up to the internet itself and the popularity of blogging, but the non-Christians blog too and they are still making paper zines. Non-Christians are self-publishing up a storm out there, with zines available on every conceivable subject and personal interest.

Are Christians unaware of the zine phenomenon since it is something we don't run into because it is outside our subculture? Honestly, I did not know of the plethora of zines out there myself, even when I began making my own publications many years ago, when I was a non-Christian. Since zines are by their nature outside the mainstream, they are not something you will see very often unless you are looking. But when I finally did start looking, I was surprised that more Christians are not using this medium for self-expression and outreach.

If you do a Google search (and perhaps look back to your own non-Christian past or interactions with non-Christians) you will find that there is a widespread stereotype among unbelievers that Christians are boring and one-dimensional. Of course, we know this is not the case, since we know ourselves and our Christian friends, and we see people who are vibrant conversationalists, musicians, artists of various stripes, voracious readers, scholars of many disciplines, gracious homemakers, craftspeople, and (insert interest, hobby or vocation here). Since zines are something tangible that can be put out in places like laundromats, bus stops, coffee-houses and other public or semi-public places where unbelievers find themselves, more Christian zines would give those unbelievers the opportunity to see that Christians Are People Too, and that we have interests in the same common grace pursuits they find themselves engaged in.

This kind of bridging-the-gap apologetics can help the non-Christian get over what is often their major objection (deserved or no) to Christianity - its adherents (this means us, folks).

Some common objections from those who might be intrigued by the idea of zinemaking could be 1) that you don't know how to do layout and design or desktop publishing, or 2) that you don't know how to express yourself in writing, or 3) that you don't have anything to say and those unbelievers are right about Christians being boring if they are talking about you. The facts are, however, that 1) many zines are put together completely sans computer, and 2) many are mostly drawings or collage or random ways of getting your point across and 3) since you are the only one who has ever lived your life with its unique combination of experiences, thoughts and talents, you do have something to say, and what you say can reach people in ways no one else could. If you would like to try, but just don't know where to begin, there are various online tutorials online about zinemaking, including a very brief workshop I had on my blog here and here.

We know that we are to do all things to the glory of God, and I think zinemaking is a great way for us to bring Him glory, because it shows forth His handiwork in the great diversity of people he has created, as well as being a medium wherein we can promote fellowship between believers, as well as "...give a defense to everyone who asks you the reason for the hope that is in you..." (1 Peter 3:15). This is not to say that a Christian's zine would necessarily be overtly theological or evangelistic, for God can and does uses the diverse everyday callings and vocations of His people to reach others. Showing and sharing your life and thoughts in this creative way will not fail to be a testimony to His grace, since you are living that life in faith.

If you have any questions or thoughts about zines and/or zinemaking, feel free to comment here or email me personally and I will help you all I can. Perhaps someday we might glimpse a beginning of the Christian Zine Revolution! That would be great reading, and I hope that in the future, I will be able to curl up on the couch with a stack of them to peruse over coffee.

Comments

I love your attitude! I've been posting my Christian "blogzine" for Moms for the last 6 weeks or so, with the thought that I really should have a print version too... And why not? I have a dandy inkjet printer that could easily be pressed into service. I've even installed a "print this" button on my site, with the thought that my visitors might want to carry my blog with them. Thanks for your inspiring comments, and I'll "play" with this idea some more. Blessings!

Posted by: e-Mom at June 20, 2006 5:38 AM

There are a few Christian e-zines out there. Boundless (http://boundless.org) and Relevant (http://relevantmagazine.com) are geared toward a young (20-somethings) audience.

Posted by: Lee Anne Millinger at June 20, 2006 10:09 AM

Lee Anne, I just love PAPER so much...e-zines just can't go with you to the potty, hehehehe.

E-mom, put me on the list for your paper zine! And your blog looks like a good one, too!

Posted by: Samantha at June 20, 2006 4:39 PM

You can't take blog-zines into the tub either... You're on my list for paper. I'll keep you posted!

I'll check out Lee Ann's Christian zine suggestions now. Are you aware of Christian Women Online (http://www.christianwomenonline.net/)? Don't think they have "hard copy" though.

Posted by: e-Mom at June 20, 2006 6:40 PM

One thing I want to make clear, for people who have never seen a paper zine, is that not only is the content of zines that is highly original and usually *personal* , but also the layout and design is something you would never see online.

Go here on my blog to see examples of real paper zines (past ones of mine and also some done by others):
Zine Workshop 2

There is a sameness to pretty much all you see online (not that this is bad, it is just the nature of the medium) and I really appreciate the originality you see in zine layouts (even if sometimes they are less than "good design")

Posted by: Samantha at June 20, 2006 7:31 PM

Do church newsletters count as "zines"? ;)

A little more seriously - why or why not?

Posted by: Dana at June 21, 2006 10:12 PM

Wow, Dana...great question. And I make our church newsletter in addition to making zines.

My answer to your question would be "no".

First, because probably most church papers have editorial and layout/design *oversight*. I think one of the hallmarks of zines is that they are completely independent, without heirarchy involved in their production.

Second, because in a church newsletter situation there are people to be *pleased* (or at least people not to rattle). THis is not to say that a Christian's zine should ever seek to be personally offensive to anyone of fail to bring God glory in other ways, but a zine is usually not a place where you would worry about "demographics" or who will read your zine. It would be rare to see something very controversial or something about underwater basketweaving in a church paper because this is a factor. People reading a church paper usually *expect* certain kinds of content, and while certain zines may have loose themes, the unexpected is likely to crop up.

You could probably tell if looking at my zines and the church paper that I do the layout and design on both, and I enjoy laying out the church paper, but my heart and soul is in my zines because it is a personal creation from the ground up.

Posted by: Samantha at June 22, 2006 9:57 AM

If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.

About

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.