« Christian women in the academy, part 1 | Main | invisible idols »

On addiction

addiction, n. 1. the condition of being addicted (to a habit); habitual inclination.

addicted, a. devoted or given up (to a practice or habit, especially a bad habit.) Syn. – devoted, accustomed, prone, attached, habituated, disposed, inclined, abandoned.

Addiction is a difficult thing. It’s something that’s not easy to talk about, especially for those who’ve struggled with it. Which would include me, but I guess I’d like talk about it anyway.

Probably the greatest factor influencing any kind of addiction is discomfort, or pain –- emotional or mental discomfort/pain, most likely, but perhaps physical pain as well. The pain may involve shame, guilt, feelings of insecurity, self-loathing, or depression, in varying degrees. Most of all, the addicted person lacks ability to deal with very strong and perhaps confused feelings, thoughts, and desires, usually of the negative type but sometimes of distorted-positive type as well, which are often exacerbated by the addiction itself.

Persons may have difficulty dealing with pain or managing out-of-control thoughts and feelings because they have been very deeply wounded. They may have suffered at the poor treatment of important persons in their lives, i.e., family members, relatives, friends, teachers, or coaches. Or they may not have had good role models for the proper handling of emotions and thoughts (negative ones especially) nor anyone to help them deal with these things, in their formative years especially. Perhaps they were punished for even having negative feelings or thoughts. How many “normal” people don’t have trouble dealing with these things, let alone someone who hasn’t been “allowed” to have them? It’s that much worse for the truly abused or profoundly hurt person, who may go through all sorts of inner turmoil trying to make sense of negative experiences and the resulting emotions and thoughts. It’s natural to want to try to end the torment, both external and internal, and to go to great (if misguided) lengths to do so.

A person may become addicted to something in order to try to escape pain even though he/she knows it only works temporarily and in the long run actually adds to the pain. Such a person may become addicted to a certain pleasure (not necessarily a “vice,” but anything, even something legitimate, that causes pleasure, indulged in an intemperate way) in order to avoid dealing with some part of his/her reality. Such persons may try hard to find ways to feel adequate, significant, or valuable in various pursuits that are not ultimately healthy. They either do not know how to express their thoughts, desires, and strong emotions properly within their relationships, work habits, and hobbies, or else have no one with whom to safely do so, so they pour their desires and strong emotions into an unhealthy pursuit. (They cannot trust.) Such situations therefore become prisons, trapping persons inside and exacerbating their distress.

Others perhaps punish themselves with habits they otherwise justify, but, in moments of honesty and transparency, are aware of what they are doing. The resulting feelings then cause a downward spiral. Often the escape and the punishment occur within the same activity.

Sometimes it’s hard to draw the line between something merely relied upon and an actual addiction. We all rely on many things every day. Some things we can do without, some we really can’t. Some things we become used to, and if those things change, for whatever reason, we find ourselves grieving or going through a withdrawal of sorts. This is quite normal. But it becomes abnormal if the feelings and thoughts get put into some practice or habit that keeps a person from truly dealing with them to the point of resolution.

As to overcoming addiction, there are treatment centers, books, support/discussion/prayer groups, and counselors for the purpose. But there is another major source that may be under-availed: people willing to befriend those who are troubled, appreciate them for who they are, and get close enough to provide a listening ear and a safe haven. It may take a fairly strong person to do this, but what a ministry. Wouldn’t it be helpful if long-time friends were willing to “go into” areas that are usually avoided because they’re awkward & uncomfortable, or because the friends think they wouldn’t know what to do or say to help, or don’t want to invade unspoken boundaries? Boundary issues are certainly a legitimate and necessary consideration, but perhaps they ought to be reassessed and redrawn in certain situations.

Surely the most fundamental way an addicted person can be helped is in the same way any person who’s dealing with a traumatic situation can be helped: through friends being there for them and listening to them. Through being treated with dignity, as if they are “normal,” and as if their feelings and thoughts matter. “Rejoice with those who rejoice, weep with those who weep.” (Romans 12:15)

Those who are troubled need to step out and risk revealing their insecurities, which can be difficult since they may lack the skills to do so properly and/or they’ve had their vulnerability trampled in the past. Often personal boundary issues are involved because troubled individuals have had their own boundaries violated by those in whom they put their trust.

Obviously, though, if persons in either position cannot put aside their trepidations, then not much healing can take place.

This healing may include “unlearning” the lessons of pain, lessons that have imparted confusion and feelings of worthlessness. Wounded persons may need to learn that in bearing suffering or difficulty without seeking an instant escape, they may truly find their identity in Christ. Christ is the ultimate example of one who took on humiliation and abuse that He did not deserve. By seeing wounded-ness in this light, a person can find value in being made in the imago dei as well as strength from identity in Christ as a person redeemed and called for a purpose. A person can find strength to forgive, and thus gain insight into the pain of the one(s) who have caused pain, by learning to rely on God rather than created things. Empathy and compassion bloom in such a healed heart and mind, leading to restored relationships and healthier social interaction. Increased understanding and cultivation of a tender heart are benefits also reaped by the friend who’s helped salve a wounded heart/mind.

You may have thought that this post was over, but there’s one more thing I’d like to throw in: that of addiction and the unregenerate person. No doubt there are many unregenerate persons who are slaves to all sorts of addictions. But addictions are not limited to the unregenerate; I’m sure we all agree on that. So my statements above are made with the assumption that many a person suffering addiction of some sort can be “evangelized” or otherwise brought closer to Christ via loving fellowship. (And, indeed, some addictions are more severe than others, or more destructive than others...perhaps there is no one completely free...?)

Comments

I am interested to know what you think about the term "addiction" being used as a euphemism for something that has a name in the Bible...something like "sexual addiction" for what the Bible calls "adultery".

I am not asking this question from a holier-than-thou perspective...I was a regular marijuana smoker well into my Christian life. But I do think that something which is given a name in Scripture as a serious sin, should not be softened with euphemisms which seem to make the situation seem to be something that is really outside a person's control, when in reality it is always a moment by moment choice., even if that choice boils down to the option of having to check oneself into a hospital where they do not have access, say, to heroin or another substance.

When I finally came to the point when I *knew* I would not smoke marijuana anymore, we had our pastor come over to talk with us about it. One of the things he did was make clear all the risks we took all the years we smoked, that we chose to conveniently put out of our minds. When we looked at it that way, we saw that for many years, our smoking was more important to us than our children, my husband's livelihood, etc., and we chose to ignore all those things. But the most serious issue was that we were choosing to go to something other than God for strength and for comfort and solace, and we were also unwilling to deal with the difficulties of life and allow God to work through them for our sanctification.

I gues my point is that while we definitely need to have compassion for those who deal with addictions, I really think that any addiction is not only a physical problem (if the addiction is to a substance), but a heart issue and most probably a sin, namely the sin of idolatry. Our pastor did a great job pointing out our sin, while at the same time showing us lots of compassion without judgement.

Posted by: Samantha at December 2, 2005 11:12 AM

Hi Samantha,

No question that addiction is a sin – I’d go so far as to say that it’s always a sin. I don’t believe that the sin of addiction should be treated euphemistically at all. Not all addictions can be “healed” by the same method though, obviously, and I think that sometimes people are trapped in addictions because, while they choose them, they may not be clear on how to make a better choice, or may fear what their life might be like without the addiction. (I didn’t address that aspect in the post). It can be really hard for an addicted person to get out of an addiction by themselves, without support from significant persons in their lives.

Speaking of which, your pastor sounds like a wonderful man. It’s not every pastor who knows how to counsel well, unfortunately.

I focused on pain as a cause of addiction in my post though I agree that it ultimately comes down to moral choice. I believe, though, that addicted individuals can be quite confused about morality (lacking in understanding) and unable to see all of their choices clearly until these are pointed out by a caring individual. Probably some who are addicted are not as aware of pain as others or aware at of it at all, though I don’t know. I don’t speak on the subject as an expert, which is probably obvious from the post.

The problem with labeling something “sin” as such and dealing with it in the abstract is that focus may then center on the label "sin" out of the context of forgiveness. A person's sin may then be treated out of context with their entire being. But a sin is not a thing unto itself in a person's life. Sometimes probably even the addicted person can get so focused on the addiction that they don’t see the “big picture” either. In saying this, though, I am not saying that non-condemnation of the sinner equals non- condemnation of the sin. Rather, I’m attempting to illustrate that condemnation of the sin must not equal condemnation of the sinner.

Of course, if loving efforts to help another are rejected, then the only thing left to do is pray.

Another thing I was subtly (indirectly) looking at in the post is the heart/mind (false) dichotomy. I think that people tend to split the two, or ignore one for the other (or emphasize one over the other) when dealing with sin, but the two go hand in hand. Emotional and mental issues must be addressed together; I think that "heart issues" are really "heart-and-mind issues".

Thanks for your comment, Samantha.

Posted by: Bonnie at December 3, 2005 8:59 AM

Bonnie, this was not a lead balloon! (I had to giggle at the metaphor, though.) I think the seriousness of my duty (and the weight of my failure to do so) is what silenced me upon reading this. I have a really fatal tendency to suppose, though, that part of my duty includes actually saving the person, and not merely putting forth every reasonable effort to point them to salvation, be it from an addiction or any other besetting sin. I should have at least commented to tell you thank you for the reminder.

Posted by: Laura at December 4, 2005 7:51 PM

Thanks for the reassurance, Laura. Guess I can stop worrying about being crushed now (under the lead balloon). My own fatal tendency is self-doubt -- I fear I am an island, both in blogging and in real life. And I don’t like it!

I am glad that there was some benefit from my post. Of course you were under no obligation to do so, but I appreciate you letting me know :-)

Posted by: Bonnie at December 4, 2005 8:22 PM

Hi Bonnie,
I like the spirit of the post. On this:
support/discussion/prayer groups, and counselors for the purpose. But there is another major source that may be under-availed: people willing to befriend those who are troubled

They aren't separate groupings (except counsellor) - many people make friends through support/discussion/prayer groups. Many people make friends in 12 step programs. So people in those kind of groups are not necessarily friendless or without people who are alongside.

People become addicted for several reasons. Trauma is one - and they are self-medicating by using their addictive substance. And I think it helps to clarify what is meant by addiction. Substance dependency includes physical addiction. Marijuana has physical consequences but is generally a psychological addiction (although I'm open to rare exceptions).

Addiction can be a catch-all term but there are stages of severity. Sometimes the best thing a friend can do is strongly recommend a detox!

Some thoughts there. I guess I'd add that pain also has degrees of severity. Like the woman I worked with who had been gang raped at the age of 13. She could stop using the drugs - but then was flooded with flashback memories of the trauma. We say God can heal but sometimes that is a process - and rather than using words like sin and idolatry (which makes a woman like her simply feel judged and even more like damaged goods due to the incredibly negative image she already has of herself) I prefer to talk about restoring dignity.

We can talk about choices - but not everyone has the same choices. Some people's choices are more limited than others. If both your parents were angry alcoholics who beat you from the time you could walk - what would you have learned about choices available?

Just be Jesus to people. He knows what a persons choices were and what he can forgive and heal. We can be a living example of a better choice.

Posted by: Catez at December 7, 2005 4:47 PM

Since I am the one who maintained that addiction is sin and idolatry, I will respond to Catez' comment.

While we are all sinful and broken people, who are so easily wounded, that doesn't mean that just because someone sins against us we are then not sinning when we respond to that in sinful ways. In the Bible, Joseph was sinned against, Sarah was sinned against, Paul was sinned against, Christ Himself was sinned against, and we don't see any of them responding by developing an addiction.

My thoughts on addiction being sin, also, were in the context of Christians who have addictions, and how I have heard *pastors* describe a particular sinful behaviour, which is named and called sin in the Bible, yet labeling it "an addiction".

When you are dealing with a non-Christian who has an addiction, I agree that the first thing you need to do with them is point them to the one who cleanses and heals. But after they are converted, while you still have to deal with them in gentleness and compassion, you have to deal with their behaviour in a different way, because now they have the Lord from Whom to draw their strength, and other believers to encourage them, rebuke them, and hold them accountable.

I think it is like a person who is a homosexual...if they are an unbeliever, to reach them you don't focus on the specific sin of their homosexuality, but on their sinful condition and need for Christ. After they become Christians, however, if they are still involved in homosexual behaviour, the Biblical thing to do is deal with that behaviour, calling it sin, and encouraging repentance.

Posted by: Samantha at December 9, 2005 7:39 AM

Perhaps what’s called for is a distinction between truth and compassion, so that truth can be known yet handled graciously and spoken in love. Actually, compassion itself is truth – we are called to humility, service, and gentleness as well as wisdom and discernment. This is true love.

Internet Monk has a very interesting post* on whether or not there’s mental illness in the Bible, and, while he mentions addiction by name only briefly (in regards to Samson), he makes what I think are several important and applicable points.

One of his points is that whether or not a particular sin is a result of mental illness or not, both sin and mental illness are a result of the fall. Both have both voluntarily and involuntarily sinful aspects, i.e., elements that we have choice over and elements that can’t be got rid of, because they are part of the sin nature. I believe that the same can be said for addiction. In fact, addiction probably represents mental and/or emotional illness as well as spiritual illness (there’s that false dichotomy again...I’d even say that distinguishing mental, emotional, and even physical illness from spiritual illness can get dicey. Not that the flu is a spiritual illness, but spiritual health or lack thereof can have physical, mental, and emotional effects.).

I am finding of myself lately that perhaps I have identified my “thorn in the flesh:” I thought I was rid of some things that perhaps I shall never be rid of. Though I sure wish I could be. Perhaps I will always have certain predispositions. However, I may choose either to walk in them or to walk in the Spirit and love I have learned of from God. I can learn to behave properly despite my tendencies not to in certain things. This is where the line between plain old sinfulness-of-man and mental or emotional illness gets fuzzy. It's the reason I tried to make the point (at the end of my post) that health is a continuum of degree, and that none of us are exempt from temptation to addiction of some sort and to some degree (though I could be wrong!)

*actually he’s written a series on the subject, see this post. (interesting discussion in the comment threads as well) I haven’t read the whole series yet but plan to.


Catez, it is true that support groups offer places for people to find friends who have similar struggles, but that itself can become a kind of ghetto – I do not say this to in any way insult or diminish the importance of these kinds of groups or friends; I think they are necessary. But these groups are not the entire body of Christ; they are merely a part. My point in what I’ve been saying is that the whole body should get involved, and the struggling ought to have supportive friends from many and various parts of the body. Also, it's too bad if a person needs separate friends for different "parts" of themselves; not that this isn't normal and natural in some respects, but a good friend ought not be so limited.

Samantha -- Joseph was loved very much by his Dad. Don't know what Sarah's or Paul's situations were but I think that a good parental relationship can make a huge difference in the way people respond to injury. Often it's deep injury from a parent or parents themselves that leads people to get into other lousy relationships as well as bad behaviors and practices.

Thanks for the discussion!

Posted by: Bonnie at December 10, 2005 9:24 AM

Hi Bonnie,
I have previously worked professionally in the addiction field. You seem to b talking about Christians with addictions. I was thinking about non-Christians. There's a challenge!

Posted by: Catez at December 12, 2005 8:14 AM

LOL you’re right, Catez...actually, at first I was thinking about anyone with an addiction, Christian or non-, and really I still am. But perhaps my focus shifted a little in there somewhere :-). I'm sure there would need to be some differences in the way treatment of addiction is approached depending on “where the person is” regarding faith, but there would also be a lot of similarities.

It seems to me there’s a long continuum between mental/emotional health and un-health, and we all slide around on it somewhere and to different extents, perhaps even being conglomerations of both in different proportions at different times. iMonk’s series raises some really important questions and issues regarding Christians and mental health, and I hope to post comments on it.

Posted by: Bonnie at December 12, 2005 8:41 PM

If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.

About

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.