« Spotlight on Darfur 2 | Main | Faith and Doubt »

Putting All Our Eggs in One Basket: Cloning Project Manipulates Women

The Pacific Fertility Center of San Francisco intends to recruit women to donate eggs for cloning and embryonic stem cell research for the South Korea-based World Stem Cell Foundation, which announced this week that it is opening a satellite operation in the San Francisco Bay area.

According to the Fertility Center's Dr. Philip Chenette, "women are fascinated by by the chance to help." Of course they are interested in the chance to help. The alternative response to the request would be "no, I'm not interested in helping people who are dying of diseases that research might prove to benefit."

Cloning and embryonic stem cell research depends upon the willingness of women to risk their own health and even their lives in order to produce eggs for research that they are told will help save lives (while, obviously, destroying lives - another issue for another blog entry). What real choice does a woman have to say "no" to such a request? The liberal side of our culture says that a woman has a right to make choices about her own body, but that real choices are often obscured by oppression, coercion, and power-mongering. Doesn't anyone else see how this project is exactly that and amounts to a pure objectification of women? The feminist outcry is barely a whisper at this point.

Comments

The day that S.Korea announced their new project, a reporter on NPR actually noted that they have a "culture of egg donation" in that country. What does that mean?

I, too, am appalled at the lack of outrage among feminists. This is a full out frontal assault upon the female gift of giving life -- and no one seems to care.

Posted by: Jordan at October 21, 2005 7:10 PM

Why be appalled? Women who fight for abortion rights should not be expected to fight to save mere eggs. Women who fight for under-age children to receive an abortion without notifying the parents should not be expected to care about the health and life of those submitting to medical procedures under duress.

Feminists are not a force for true freedom for women: they promise freedom, but ... 2 Peter 2:19

Posted by: Susan at January 1, 2006 5:02 PM

If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.

About

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.