May 9, 2007

Notes on Blogging:
The RSS Reader as Blog Tool (Part I)


For the first three years I was a blogger, I remained a blogroll purist. I steadfastly refused to use an RSS reader to keep track of the blogs I read on a daily basis. Every night I would spend hours trawling through the fifty blogs on my blogroll. That was the proper manner for a blogger. Real bloggers, I would snobbishly contend, read blogs not feeds.

Then one day, on a whim, I decided to test Google Reader and my blogging was forever changed. The change was like trading in a horse and buggy for a Hummer.

The RSS reader entirely changed the paradigm of blogging by reducing the attention cost I paid for each blog. Currently, I have 130 feeds yet every blog--indeed every post--gets my attention every single day. In economic terms, the cost per post in processing time has dropped considerably, allowing me to spend more of my attention on a greater number of blogs. I'm also able to keep track of interesting posts and links by combining my RSS reader and email account into a "blog filing system." (More on this in part II.)

Using an RSS reader also changed the way I viewed blogging. When I started in 2003, I coveted a spot on other people's blogrolls. Now I realize the prime real estate is in a person's RSS reader. This shift is subtle but profound. The blogroll is hierarchical and labor intensive. Unless the blogroll is very short, most bloggers will not click through to every site every day. Therefore, the blogs listed on the top of the blogroll tend to be read more often than those in the middle and near the bottom of the list. Being on a blogroll doesn’t necessarily increase the likelihood of your blog being read.

Though it happens extremely quickly, each time the blogger examines his blogroll they are faced with a range of decisions. Is this a blog I have to read everyday to keep up with? Is the blogger likely to have written a post that I can use today? What if they have a good post that I want to read later? Not even my favorite bloggers could make it past such an intensive decision process every single day.

Another useful--though largely unrecognized--benefit of using a RSS reader is that it reduces distractions and extraneous context. By trying to express their individuality through their blog's design, bloggers tend to get in the way of their own content.

To see what I mean, look at the dress code of the modern teenager. One of the biggest challenges I faced on recruiting duty was explaining to teenagers what I call the paradox of uniformity. They believed that expressing themselves by how they wore their clothes, hair, makeup, or jewelry helped them to stand out from the crowd. Instead, it merely provided signals about their chosen subgroups.

Whether the signals provided clues about class (rich kids wear expensive clothes), sub-culture (skaters sporting funky haircuts), or interests (a t-shirt of their favorite band), they provided a useful means for the teens to pigeonhole themselves into their chosen stereotypes. (The extremes of nonconformity often lead to the most extreme conformity. Have you ever seen a "Goth" that didn't look like every other Goth since the 1980s?)

Paradoxically, forced standards of conformity (such as wearing a military uniform) cause people to send and receive signals about personality in ways other than dress. The individual personality traits of people in the military tend to stand out more for their colleagues because they are not camouflaged by the normal civilian clothing signals.

The same is true for the "dressing" that accompanies blog post. Take, for example, my friend Mark Olson (hopefully he won't mind me picking on him). While his blog's layout is clean and uncluttered, the purple and green color scheme is hideous. There is also a photo of Mark in spandex and a bike helmet and the subtitle, "Christianity, Cycling, and Current Events from Right of Center."

If I were to rely solely on contextual clues, I'd get the impression that the blog was mostly about cycling. Yet I've been reading Mark's writings for years and can't recall a single post that mentioned a bike. Instead, I read his work because he is a first-class intellect who grapples with serious theological and philosophical topics. By filtering his posts through my RSS reader I get distraction-free content. I can focus on the contents of Mark's big brain rather than on the color of his bike helmet.

This is not to say that blog design and individual style are unimportant. Aesthetics certainly has an essential place in blogging. I do believe, though, that when it comes to blogs, bad design is far more harmful than good design is helpful. Ultimately, though, content is king; which is why the RSS reader is supplanting the blogroll as a blog's throne room

trackbacks and bookmarks

bookmark this post:
send a trackback for this entry:
http://www.evangelicaloutpost.com/mt/mt-trackback.cgi/3586


comments
Kyle writes:

1

1. People actually used to click through their own blogrolls? Every day? Ouch! :)
2. "By filtering his posts through my RSS reader I get distraction-free content." Yes. Which is why I wish more people`would include their whole post in the feed. Far too many people include only the briefest synopsis. For instance, the RSS feed to this post included just over 2 sentences. For the rest, I had to click through to the blog site. Is there a reason for this?

posted on 05.09.2007 7:19 AM
M.R.H. writes:

2

Some blogs allow the writer to only "feed" the first few lines. Usually there is an option in the settings that allows you to quickly change this.

If you employ that option, you should do what journalists have always tried to do -- put the most important, eye-catching info in the first few lines.

BTW, Joe, you are on my RSS feed :)

posted on 05.09.2007 9:02 AM
Mark Olson writes:

3

In my defense, my youngest daughter chose the colors. My visual aesthetics regarding color, size and so on for UI design has always been a weakness. She picks my clothes too for similar reasons ... I wonder if I should seek other help. ;)

But more importantly, thanks for the high praise on my writing.

posted on 05.09.2007 9:20 AM
Mark Olson writes:

4

Kyle,

From the Wordpress config:

Note: If you use the feature, it will cut off posts in RSS feeds.

For example, I include "full text" in the RSS feed, but the "more" clips it. I use "more" just as many other writers do, to get more of the headline and a leading paragraphs at the top, allowing other readers to click and read the rest if I've managed to catch their interest.

For a short time I didn't include the full text in the RSS as an experiment to see if that changed my "hit count" statistics (it didn't). I stopped that when I realized that to be honest to myself I'm not blogging for hits, I'm blogging to help me think about things and to have discussions on those matters as well.

posted on 05.09.2007 9:28 AM
Tim L writes:

5

I don't understand what you mean by RSS reader? Can't you just use RSS in your browser? Safari has it built in and I have been using the RSS link to know when you have updated your site quite a while now Joe! Fridays and Sundays I often see no updates and this morning there was (3) behind your RSS link website.

Now I have to go and see about this RSS reader! Do I want to just continue using my browser (and have them all open in multiple tabs at once) or start using a reader?

posted on 05.09.2007 11:01 AM
kbiel writes:

6

Tim L,

Google reader is an AJAX "application" that works quite well in both IE and Firefox. It is one of my two home pages that open when I load Firefox. For bloggers that put all of the text of their posts into the RSS feed, it is great. It allows me to read the entirety of their posts and focus on the content in a single visual style regardless of which blog it came from. There is nothing to install; you just need a Google account.

posted on 05.09.2007 11:57 AM
Collin Brendemuehl writes:

7

In retrospect, is Max reading these? ;-)

Collin
http://evangelicalperspective.blogspot.com

posted on 05.09.2007 9:17 PM
post a comment
comment








remember personal info?






email this link
email this entry to:


your email address:


message (optional):