May 18, 2004

A Protestant, a Pope, and a Pardon


While I admit that having President Bush apologize for the events at Abu Ghraib prison may be having a beneficial effect (at least on the Arab media), this proposal is going a bit too far:

President Bush should kneel before Pope John Paul and ask for forgiveness for abuses committed by U.S. soldiers in Iraq, Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez says.

In his latest jibe against the U.S. leader, the outspoken left-wing Venezuelan president urged Bush to use his planned visit to the Vatican on June 4 to announce the withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq.

"Even though he's not a Catholic ... he should ask God's forgiveness at the Vatican ... go down on his knees in front of the Pope and ask for the forgiveness of the world, not just the Iraqi people," Chavez told a news conference Friday in Caracas.

That whirring sound coming from Wittenberg, Germany is Martin Luther spinning in his grave.


comments
David writes:

1

Wow! I did not realize Chavez got his marching orders from the DNC!

This guy sounds like such a joke.

posted on 05.18.2004 12:31 PM
Rob Ryan writes:

2

Luther still hasn't stopped spinning from the broad Protestant support for Israel that characterizes the modern era. He would have preferred to see the Jews converted or destroyed.

posted on 05.18.2004 2:33 PM
cdm writes:

3

If anyone knows and adheres to the "classical reformered" teaching on Popery, you can really get an ugly picture of this proposal.

posted on 05.18.2004 3:05 PM
Puzzled writes:

4

Chavez, the Castroite communist dictator of Venezeula, enemy of the church, enemy of the people. Real credible source of Christian wisdom.

Rob,
You libel Dr. Martin.

posted on 05.18.2004 3:09 PM
fartinmartin writes:

5

nah - that's him spinning on his spit. Lucifer is warming him up ready for his next doner kebab.

posted on 05.18.2004 3:29 PM
Amy Ridenour writes:

6

If anyone does any apologizing when President Bush meets with the Pope, it should be the Pope on account of his continuing employment of a secretary of state who publicly makes light of 9-11.

posted on 05.18.2004 11:45 PM
what?? writes:

7

oh my gosh is this for real??

posted on 05.19.2004 5:18 AM
James the Catholic convert writes:

8

Napoleon, not King Philip II of Spain, is the model for church-state relations in most Spanish-speaking countries. Few Protestants realize how secular most Latin American governments are. Mexico, for instance, reluctantly opened a Vatican embassy after the USA and prohibits its President from any sort of public religious participation. The Sandinistas did everything in their power to embarrass and discredit Pope John Paul when he visited during the early eighties.

The President of Venezuela is no more likely than John Kerry to kiss the Pope's ring and publicly ask for the sacrament of penance. His suggestion to President Bush is not the least bit serious.

posted on 05.19.2004 12:01 PM
Tom R writes:

9

"Few Protestants realize how secular most Latin American governments are."

James is right. Graham Greene's novel The Power and the Glory is an eye-opener. I was brought up on tales of brave hedge priests being persecuted by the Protestant majority in England. So it was a shock to read how viciously anti-clerical the [semi-]elected gov't of a Catholic-majority nation like Mexico had become.

Tangentially to that, Greene includes a pair of American Lutherans who are two of the novel's most sympathetic characters (although -- of course -- they "just don't understand" Catholicism).

posted on 05.19.2004 8:38 PM
Tom R writes:

10

"Napoleon, not King Philip II of Spain, is the model for church-state relations in most Spanish-speaking countries."

[Cont'd] Part of the reason may be that, on average, most Protestant-majority nations became democratic long before most Catholic-dominated countries. Democracies are prone to persecuting minorities but one thing they almost never do is pick on the majority group. So if the USA a hundred years ago was 80% Prot, this means its laws are not likely to discriminate against Prot mores and doctrines. But if a country is a monarchy or a despotism, it can be 90% Catholic and yet still discriminate against Catholicism (think Jacobin France, secularist Mexico, Communist Poland... and arguably, Republican Spain and large swathes of England at the start of the Reformation).

posted on 05.19.2004 8:58 PM