January 23, 2004

Stossel, Sharpton, and Stupidity


John Stossel is the thinking man's Bill O'Reilly. While the geezers at 60 Minutes keep a straight face when someone spouts nonsense, Stossel doesn't even try to hide the fact that he isn't buying the BS.

Tonight on a 20/20 special 'Lies, Myths and Downright Stupidity”, Stossel exposed some of the most common myths that many people take as conventional wisdom. To present Myth No. 5 -- 'The Rich Don't Pay Their Fair Share of Taxes” -- Stossel interviewed presidential candidate Al Sharpton:

We've all heard this one during the presidential campaign. When it comes to income taxes, the Democratic presidential candidates keep telling us, the rich don't pay enough.

That's a widespread belief, but do the politicians even know how much of the income tax burden the rich pay now?

According to presidential candidate Al Sharpton, "The top one percent in this country pays very much less than ten percent, very much less than five percent."

Sharpton said he thinks the wealthy should pay "somewhere around 15 percent."
But that's so silly because — and I bet most of you don't know this — the IRS says the richest 1 percent of taxpayers already pay 34 percent of all income taxes. Twice what Sharpton wanted them to pay.

Still you may feel the rich should pay even more. It's a tempting thought, since they have so much.

But let's remember the facts: the top 1 percent of Americans — those who earn more than about $300,000 a year — pay 34 percent, more than a third of all income taxes, and the top 5 percent, those making over $125,000, pay more than half.

On camera, Stossel not only set Sharpton up for a fall (which the Reverend fell for) but even pointed out to him that the 'rich” paid 34% of all taxes. Sharpton quickly changed the subject.

Stossel is a national treasure. But, for the life of me, I don't know how he ever found a place on TV. I guess ABC thought that no one would be watching on Friday evening at 9 p.m. Unfortunately, they're probably right.


comments
Steve_in_Corona writes:

1

Favorite Stossel moment was a couple years ago when he did the special about the environment and what lies the elementary school kids were being taught (with our tax dollars, cough) and especially about the anti-Bush propoganda.

Yet another reason why I homeschool..

posted on 01.24.2004 12:06 AM
Captain Ed writes:

2

I watched that last night, too. I loved the moment with Sharpton -- but he's pretty self-possessed. National Review did a nice piece on Stossel; there's a link to it on RealClearPolitics from yesterday.

posted on 01.24.2004 8:14 AM
Rusty Lopez writes:

3

While the geezers at 60 Minutes keep a straight face when someone spouts nonsense...

This post is classic if not for that line alone Joe!

I think Stossel got where he is by sneaking in under the radar, establishing himself, and only then revealing his attack pattern.

posted on 01.24.2004 10:22 AM
Jared writes:

4

I agree with Rusty. I recall always looking forward to Stossel's reports on 20/20, back when he was just another TV-mag journalist. I don't recall ever getting a whiff of his libertarian-leaning views.
It wasn't until he started those "Give Me A Break" spots on 20/20 that you started to see that side of him, and even then it was somewhat discreet. When he got the co-anchor spot with Barbra Walters is when I think he really secured his pulpit.
Bully for him!

I loved that special, by the way, even though I only caught the second half. Anybody know if they'll re-air it?

posted on 01.25.2004 2:48 PM